How many days above 30C do you have each year?
You have to ask yourself whether the extra electricity you use when your current unit cycles longer on a few hot days is greater than the expense of installing a new larger unit and the extra cost of running the larger unit every hour of every other day. Larger unit = larger blower motor, larger compressor = more $ per hour to operate every day.
Newer homes, in general, are better insulated and tighter built than older homes, which allows a smaller unit to handle the A/C chores. If the smaller unit needs to run longer on hot days, and if you only have an average of a dozen hot days per year, you will be money ahead keeping your current unit. Now, if I were living in SW Houston, where it never gets cool except during tornado season

, I'd consider the larger unit.